The Rental Panthers: Florida’s All-Time Greatest Single Year Stars

The Rental Panthers: Florida’s All-Time Greatest Single Year Stars
Sean Tierney

For the first time in years, the Florida Panthers are taking a run at the playoffs. And in preparation for a stretch drive to claim the eighth playoff seed in the Eastern Conference, the Panthers did something they have rarely done in their 22-year history.

They went rental shopping.

Just prior to the deadline, the Cats snatched up the prototypical rental player, future Hall of Famer Jaromir Jagr.

With an expiring contract, a long, long history of scoring, and oodles of playoff experience, Jagr is exactly the type of player that playoff-bound teams scramble to acquire each March.

Jagr may prove to be the missing piece needed to sneak the Panthers into the playoffs. Or maybe Florida will fall short and Jagr will simply move on next season.

Regardless of their fate, the acquisition of Jagr creates an opportunity to ask: Who are the greatest one-year Florida Panthers players of all-time? Which “rental” Cats made the biggest impression during their brief stay in Florida?

Let’s take a look at the best all-time one-year wonders in Florida Panthers history – one player at each position.


Being a Rental

The Florida Panthers have only clinched a playoff berth four times since their inaugural season in 1993-94. So, a look through their history of deadline day deals does not provide many player choices.

So, for our purposes, a “rental” is any player who played no more than one season for the Panthers. For that list, take a look here.

Honourable Mentions

As with any all-time list, there are always a few players who are close to making the squad but, in the end, fall short. Players who almost made this one-year wonders lists are:


Ed Belfour

In his only season with the Florida Panthers, two-time Vezina winner Ed Belfour posted 27 wins, a 2.77 goals against average, and .902 save percentage. On a mostly-middling Panthers squad, Belfour was a bright spot.


Lyle Odelein

At the end of his career, the former Columbus Blue Jackets captain and long-time Canadiens stalwart added stability during a tumultuous year in Florida. With few one-year options on the backend, this defensive defenseman almost made the one-year wonders squad.


Alexei Kovalev

With 1029 points in 1316 games, Kovalev is likely the most prolific NHLer ever to suit up for the Panthers. That’s almost enough to make the Florida Panthers all-time one year wonders lineup. However, Kovalev’s five points in 14 games was just too little to make the final cut.


Jesse Winchester

Winchester posted 18 points in 52 games during the 2013-14 season. Known as a responsible two-way player with sneaky strong possession rates, Winchester posted a 51.8 SAT% and was a +1.6 SAT relative to his teammates. In the new NHL of advanced statistics, Winchester provided value during his only season in Florida.

The All-Time Greatest One-Year Wonders

After much deliberation, here is the Florida Panthers’ greatest all-time, one-year wonders squad.


Starting Goaltender – Mike Vernon

Dealt to the Panthers partway through the 1999-00 season, Vernon posted a 2.47 GAA (seventh-best mark in team history) and a 0.919 SV% as the Panthers claimed a playoff berth. The Panthers were swept in the first round but Vernon’s presence stabilized a team that had been out of the playoffs for a couple of seasons.

In the end, Vernon’s participation in a playoff run gives him the edge over Eddie the Eagle…but it was close.


Dennis Wideman – Defense

Dennis Wideman owns the highest point total for a single-season defenseman in Panthers history. Wideman continues to hold the best point total for any one-year Florida Panthers player excluding Aaron Ekblad (who is set to play many more seasons in Florida). Wideman wasn’t always a steady defensive defenseman but his contributions offensively have been tough to replace in Florida.

An offensively-talented defender, Wideman owns the first spot on the “one-year wonders” Florida Panthers team.


Per Gustaffson – Defense

In a somewhat thin group of notable rearguards who played only one season for the Florida Panthers, Per Gustafsson claims the other defenseman spot. After playing seven years in the Swedish Elite League, Gustafsson debuted in the 1996-97 season scoring 29 points and registering a respectable +11 rating.

Gustafsson stuck in the NHL for a couple of seasons before returning to the SEL for an astonishing 12 more seasons. His longevity and defensive responsibility earn Gustafsson the narrow nod over Odelein for the second spot on the one-year wonders Panthers squad.


Mike Foligno – Right Wing

In search of leadership and a well-known name for their expansion lineup in 1993-94, the Panthers acquired Mike Foligno from the Toronto Maple Leafs for cash. In 39 games with the Panthers, Foligno mustered nine points, 49 PIMs, and a respectable plus-seven rating.

Much like Brad Marsh’s turn with the Ottawa Senators in his final season, Foligno’s name value and leadership added much to the Panthers club as it scratched through its first NHL season.


Igor Larionov – Centre

Larionov’s ill-fated turn with the Florida Panthers doesn’t dimish the quality of Larionov’s Hall of Fame career. Larionov left the Detroit Red Wings and signed with the Panthers in 2000-01, scored 11 points in 26 games, and then was promptly traded back to Detroit mid-season.

Despite the short tenure, Larionov enjoyed an illustrious career; 644 points in 921 games, puck possession wizardry, a lifetime 16.2 shooting percentage, three Stanley Cups, and induction into the Hall of Fame. Larionov’s stellar career overall earns this rental Panther a spot on the one-year wonders lineup.


Sergei Samsonov – Left Wing

Sergei Samsonov joined the Panthers for 20 games at the end of the 2010-11 season, scoring 14 points. The diminutive, enigmatic, and skilled forward provided offensive punch for a Panthers’ squad whose high-scorer – Stephen Weiss – potted just 49 points. At his scoring pace over a full season, Samsonov would have been Florida’s top scorer.

After his single season in Florida, Samsonov retired. This decision made him the perfect choice at left wing for the one-and-done Florida Panthers team.

With Mike Vernon in goal, Dennis Wideman and Per Gustafsson on defense, and Igor Larionov centering Mike Foligno and Sergei Samsonov, the best of the Florida Panthers rental players is a unit with some offense, some grit, little defense, and some Hall of Fame clout.

Will Jaromir Jagr or another one-year wonder can join this group eventually? Only time will tell.

What do you think, Florida Panthers fan? Does one of the honourable mentions deserve a spot on this lineup? Is Eddie Belfour just too good to be Mike Vernon’s backup?

One Pingback/Trackback

Sean Tierney

Sean Tierney writes articles about Atlantic Division teams, working to include analytics whenever possible. He has also written about the Leafs, Habs, Sens, Raptors, and Blue Jays for Fansided, The Hockey Writers, and Bleacher Report. He enjoys long walks on the beach and candle lit dinners and definitely isn’t the tallest guy in the men’s rec basketball league.

More in Atlantic

NHL: APR 11 Bruins at Lightning

Breaking Down Bruins’ General Manager Search

Chris WasselApril 28, 2015
OHL: OCT 15 Erie Otters at London Knights

Toronto Maple Leafs Should Target Mitch Marner

Caitlin CampbellApril 27, 2015

Carey Price is a Vezina Trophy Lock

Sean TierneyApril 27, 2015
NHL: APR 24 Round 1 - Game 5 - Senators at Canadiens

Montreal Canadiens Digging Themselves a Hole

Chris WasselApril 26, 2015
NHL: APR 23 Round 1 - Game 4 - Lightning at Red Wings

Mike Babcock Has Unique Opportunity as an NHL Coach

Franklin SteeleApril 26, 2015

Aaron Ekblad the Clear Choice for the Calder Trophy

Sean TierneyApril 26, 2015
NHL: SEP 29 Preseason - Capitals at Bruins

Chiarelli in Edmonton Could be Win for Bruins

John TerraApril 26, 2015
NCAA HOCKEY: APR 11 Div I Men's National Championship - Providence v Boston University

Sabres Move on From McDavid and Embrace Eichel

Robert NassoApril 25, 2015
OHL: OCT 15 Erie Otters at London Knights

Dylan Strome is the most Buzzworthy Pick for Maple Leafs

Chris WasselApril 24, 2015


Slapshot on Facebook

Slapshot On Twitter

Copyright © 2014 Today’s Slapshot, All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Use/Privacy | Copyright | Site Map | About Us | Authors | Contact Us