NHL Prospects

NHL Prospects: Edmonton Oilers Top-5 for 2015

NHL Prospects: Edmonton Oilers Top-5 for 2015
Steven Ives

Edmonton Oilers 2015 Draft

The Edmonton Oilers 2015 draft will long be remembered for one thing — the day Connor McDavid donned the Edmonton sweater for the first time. With all the hullabaloo surrounding the prodigal young talent, we were half-expecting GM Peter Chiarelli to tell reporters: “We couldn’t believe he was still on the draft board when our turn came to pick.”

Lots of other things happened too.

The Oilers made a terrible trade, giving up two early draft picks for a left-shooting, mid-pairing defenseman when they could have drafted what they desperately need in a right-shooting, top-four defenseman with either pick. Then they made a good trade, giving up two mid-round draft picks for Cam Talbot, a very talented goalie who could be their starting netminder for several seasons to come.

The Oilers closed the draft on a high note with three solid picks of defensemen, Caleb Jones, Ethan Bear and John Marino.


Oilers Revised Top 5 Prospects

(Scale to 10: 10= Generational Talent, 9= Franchise Player, 8= All-Star, 7= NHL Regular, 6= Fringe NHL-er)

1. C Connor McDavid (10.0) McDavid is the first prospect I have given a 10.0 to since some kid named Sidney Crosby. But, if not him, then why even have 10.0 as an available rating? For the year 2371 AD when some kid with psychic abilities and the super-power to fly is draft eligible? I can’t wait that long, I’m giving it to McDavid.

2. C Leon Draisaitl (8.5) Draisaitl is a stud at center with Joe Thornton-like upside. However, with McDavid joining Nugent-Hopkins up the middle, there is a strong possibility Leon starts the 2015-16 season on the left wing, where he enjoyed great success in the WHL.

3. LD Darnell Nurse (8.0) The huge and physical shut-down defenseman the Oilers have long-coveted should be an integral part of the Oilers’ blueline next season. He also has good offensive upside and can skate — just a terrific prospect.

4. LD Griffin Reinhart (7.0) Reinhart brings size, mobility and depth to the Oilers blueline, and has very good upside as a mid-pairing defensive defenseman. He should slot in on the depth chart at LD behind Nurse and Klefbom.

5. RD Ethan Bear (7.0) I may hear it about my No. 5 prospect ranking and 7.0 prospect rating for Ethan Bear, just days after his selection in the 5th round of the NHL draft. I watched this kid a ton while scouting first-rounder Mathew Barzal in Seattle, and each shift I saw Bear I liked him more. He’s a team-first guy, a gamer, and plays with a heart the size of his namesake. He’s very solid in the defensive zone and also filled a point-role on the Thunderbirds No. 1 PP unit, resulting in a not-too-shabby 13 goals in his draft eligible season. Bear does all the little things coaches and teammates love out of a defenseman, and it is my firm conviction that he was an absolute steal for Edmonton with the 124th overall pick. I do not find the difference in upside between Bear and Reinhart, whom the Oilers just gave a #16 and #33 pick up for, to be very large at all.


In Conclusion

The future is tremendously bright in Edmonton. McDavid and Draisaitl are set to join an elite forward core of Taylor Hall, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Nail Yakupov and Jordan Eberle. This team will score a crazy amount of goals in the future.

The addition of Talbot solidifies the Oilers’ perpetual revolving door in between the pipes. The defense is still a question going into next season, especially on the right side. It would not surprise us to see the Oilers make one final trade before the 2015-16 campaign in order to fill this need.

It is important to reiterate that, whether or not Oilers fans liked the Reinhart deal due to the value of the draft picks they gave up, they made an impressive haul in the 4th, 5th and 6th rounds with extremely projectable defensemen. Good draft picks in the late rounds were a rarity under the administrations of Kevin Lowe and Craig MacTavish, and kudos to new GM Peter Chiarelli for doing a much better job in this respect.

  • Joe

    When it was announced at the draft that a trade was made at #16 I was unbelievably excited because with Barzal and Connor sitting there at #16 I figured the Oilers were trading down with perhaps Ottawa, which needed a 1st line center, and were giving up #16 for #18 and #48. That meant that the Oilers would have #18, #33, and #48. So then the question was who were they going to get, given needs for two RDs, a 1G and a big LW. Because of what actually happened only a few people know what if any trade down options were being offered, but that blasted trade cost the Oilers perhaps Svechnikov, Meloche, and Rasmus Andersson (or Roy, Meloche, and Greenwood), and at a minimum cost Connor/Svechnikov and Meloche or Jeremy Roy and Blackwood. It might have even worked out that the Oilers wound up with Svechnikov, Roy and Andersson… at which point they could have gone for Vladar later. It was all there, but instead…Reinhart…wonderful.

    • Truthhurts98

      Couldn’t agree more Joe. My heart sank when I heard that. Still can’t figure that one out at all, Garth Snow probably fell out of his chair laughing after that trade. I really wanted them to draft at least Meloche and Anderson. Sigh…

NHL Prospects
Steven Ives

Steven Ives is an extremely unsuccessful cryptozoologist who, when finding himself unable to find Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster, considers himself a writer. He was born in the Bronx, New York and grew up in New Jersey and somehow survived both of these things. He now lives in an area of Brooklyn where people used to shoot each other and now just shoot independent movies. He has immense experience in sports journalism, having contributed over a billion words of content to mlb.com and several hockey writing websites. He has also written for DC Comics, but that had more to do with Wonder Woman than with Pavel Datsyuk though, if you ask Steven, they both have super powers. Unlike certain former Vice Presidents of the United States, Steven admits he has made many mistakes in his life. He often finds himself in the throes of unspeakable angst due to the fact that People Magazine has never once included him in its "50 Most Beautiful People" edition. He now writes about hockey stuff for todaysslapshot.com and is hard at work on a novel which he hopes will vault him into a rarified air of artistic obscurity.

More in NHL Prospects

NHL: SEP 26 Preseason - Coyotes at Sharks

NHL Prospects: Arizona Coyotes Top-5 for 2015

Steven IvesJuly 10, 2015
NHL: JUN 06 NHL Scouting Combine

NHL Prospects: New York Islanders Top-5 for 2015

Steven IvesJuly 9, 2015
Providence's Brandon Tanev. The Merrimack College Warriors and Providence College Friars tied 1-1 in the opening Hockey East Frozen Fenway game on Saturday, January 4, 2014, at Fenway Park in Boston, Massachusetts.

Brandon Tanev Getting Look at Bruins Prospect Camp

Cat SilvermanJuly 8, 2015
AHL: OCT 18 Utica Comets at Texas Stars

NHL Prospects: Dallas Stars Top-5 for 2015

Steven IvesJuly 6, 2015
INTERNATIONAL HOCKEY: JAN 02 World Junior Championship - Finland v Sweden

NHL Prospects: Colorado Avalanche Top-5 for 2015

Steven IvesJuly 4, 2015
10 January 2015:  Washington Capitals goalie Pheonix Copley (1) warms up at the Verizon Center in Washington, D.C. where the Washington Capitals defeated the Detroit Red Wings, 3-1.

Fitting Luke Opilka and Pheonix Copley Into St. Louis’ Depth Charts

Cat SilvermanJuly 4, 2015
NHL: OCT 14 Sabres at Hurricanes

NHL Prospects: Buffalo Sabres Top-5 for 2015

Steven IvesJuly 3, 2015
AHL: APR 03 Toronto Marlies at Lake Erie Monsters

NHL Prospects - Toronto Maple Leafs Top-5

Steven IvesJuly 2, 2015
NHL: APR 04 Penguins at Blue Jackets

NHL Prospects: Blue Jackets Updated Top-5

Steven IvesJuly 2, 2015