Islanders Fans Recall Nassau Coliseum Playoff Experiences

Islanders Fans Recall Nassau Coliseum Playoff Experiences
Daniel Friedman

With their Game 7 loss to Washington, it’s the end of an era for the New York Islanders and their fans.

Nassau Coliseum, the place this team has called home since 1972 (43 years), is closing its doors as a major league venue, as the Isles move westward to the Barclays Center in Brooklyn. They leave behind a legacy that most other NHL franchises could never hope to attain, as well as a following that was far more deeply-rooted than perhaps the mainstream media gave it credit for.

For me, and for countless others, the Coliseum is the setting for countless memories. These playoffs produced even more, and I’d like to offer a glimpse of what that building means to Islander fans. Here are some of their personal recollections:


“Watching the Isles skate around with the Cup after they beat the North Stars.”

-Michele Catalano, East Meadow, NY


“Although I was young, watching Shawn Bates’ penalty shot from my dad’s shoulders. We’ve had season tickets ever since.”

-Nick Chiarelli, Plainview, NY


“The home opener this year. Just had that buzz that we knew it would be a special one.”

-Tyler Hoffman, Bethpage, NY


“When my dad dropped the puck at the 40-year anniversary. 43 years season tickets, same seats literally and figuratively. I went to my first Islander game at five-months-old, been going ever since. A lifetime of memories.”

-Mark Bernstein, Bellmore, NY


“Game 3 was AWESOME. I went with my brother, who got me into hockey, and we’ve been to plenty of games before.. But nothing matches this experience. When they skated out on the ice before the game, I had chills, goosebumps. And it was a bit emotional, knowing not many more games are being played here. I’ve never shouted and cheered so much at a game, to the point that my throat hurt the day after. And when (John Tavares) scored in OT, It was nuts. I couldn’t hear myself shout, all I remember is the hugging of strangers and jumping up and down after that goal. It was easily the most memorable and exciting experience I’ve ever had that, and I’m hoping there will still be something to top it.”

-Dylan Nill


“(Shawn) Bates penalty shot playoff game Drove all the way down from Niagara Falls, Ontario.”

-Matt DeCiccio


“Potvin’s last game when I was a kid. Lots of love but you felt the era ending.”

-Adam Rossol, Westbury, NY


“I attend the University of Albany. Traveled 3 1/2 hours to come home for the game to leave 24 hours later. Best experience ever.”

-John Colby


“I didn’t see the game winning goal go in (for Game 3) but saw (Nikolay) Kulemin start going nuts….so I started going nuts! Also, after the Boychuk play at the end of the 2nd and thinking ‘Wow! that is one of the greatest defensive plays I have ever seen!’ Getting chills hearing the crowd going nuts waiting for the team to come out before the game.”

-Tani Isaac, New Rochelle, NY


“Favorite moment was not being able to hear the PA system as the Isles came down the tunnel because it was so loud.”

-Eddie Del Castillo, Valley Stream, NY


“Gonna go with Al Arbour night (the second one, where he coached his 1500th game). DiPietro draws the four-minute high stick on Sidney Crosby. Miroslav Satan ties, then wins the game. 1500 banner raised.”

-Shawn Reischmann, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY


“It’s a toss up between two: Isles/Stars, where John Tavares had a hat trick and (Ryan) Strome scored his first goal. Isles/Pens in the 2013 playoffs.”

-Mark Aadal, Poughkeepsie, NY


“In 2007, when Miroslav Satan tied the game against the Devils with 0.7 seconds left in the third period.”

-Max Drew, Jericho, NY


“Game 3, as of now, is my Coliseum memory. My family has been season ticket holders since the beginning, and each member has their moment. My mom’s = The Cup. My dad=the years following that first Cup. My brother =Shawn Bates penalty shot. Now I have one after 100-plus games. Game 3 was definitely my favorite, and was the best I’ve been to in my 15 short years.”

-Matt Watling


“I told my dad that we will probably be here for hours for overtime, and right after I said that, John Tavares scored and my dad and I jumped together, looking at each other in such joy. I’ll never forget that moment.”

-Maxx Basso, Orange County, NY


These are just a few of so many other memories that fans have of this team and this building. It’s a shame that future generations will not have the opportunity to have their own at Nassau Coliseum.

End of an era, indeed.

Follow Daniel Friedman on Twitter @DFriedmanOnNYI

Daniel Friedman

Daniel covers the Islanders for CBS New York and has been a credentialed media member for three years. Previously, he studied under the tutelage of Stan “The Maven” Fischler. He is also a former columnist for Bleacher Report, The Hockey Writers and The Checking Line, and he joins Today’s Slapshot as their Metropolitan Division writer.

More in Metropolitan

11 April 2015: Pittsburgh Penguins head coach Mike Johnston interviews after an NHL game between the Pittsburgh Penguins and Buffalo Sabres at the First Niagara Center in Buffalo, NY.

Mike Johnston Had Penguins Executing at a High Level

James A ConleyApril 30, 2015
NHL: APR 27 Round 1 - Game 7 - Islanders at Capitals

Islanders Fall Short but are Trending Up

James A ConleyApril 29, 2015
NHL: APR 24 Round 1 - Game 5 - Penguins at Rangers

Penguins Must Address Playoff Scoring Issues

Michael PitykApril 29, 2015
NHL: MAR 29 Capitals at Rangers

Capitals Will Give Rangers all They Can Handle

James A ConleyApril 28, 2015
NHL: MAR 15 Red Wings at Penguins

Penguins Should Gauge Kris Letang’s Trade Value

Michael PitykApril 28, 2015
NHL: DEC 23 Penguins at Lightning

Penguins Have a Cornerstone Defenseman in Brian Dumoulin

Michael PitykApril 27, 2015
NHL: MAR 28 Coyotes at Penguins

Penguins Should Consider Evgeni Malkin Trade

Sebastian NorenApril 26, 2015
NHL: APR 16 Round 1 - Game 1 - Penguins at Rangers

Which Team Should the Rangers Want to Play

John TerraApril 26, 2015
NHL: APR 24 Round 1 - Game 5 - Penguins at Rangers

Penguins Begin an Offseason Filled with Uncertainty

Michael PitykApril 25, 2015


Slapshot on Facebook

Slapshot On Twitter

Copyright © 2014 Today’s Slapshot, All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Use/Privacy | Copyright | Site Map | About Us | Authors | Contact Us