Alexander Semin Could Fit With Penguins

Alexander Semin Could Fit With Penguins
Michael Pityk

There’s no secret that the Pittsburgh Penguins need some forward help on their top two lines. General manager Jim Rutherford has made it clear that any additions will come through a trade and not unrestricted free agency.

One interesting name that has been mentioned is the disgruntled forward on the Carolina Hurricanes, Alexander Semin.

He has played two seasons of his five-year, $35 million dollar contract that carries an annual cap hit of $7 million per season. Rutherford actually signed Semin to that contract while he was still with Carolina and knows him very well.

Upon singing, it looked to be a great value for the franchise as he was a point-per-game player during the lockout shortened 2012-2013 season. 2013-2014 was a bit underwhelming for the magnitude of the contract that Semin was signed to and 2014-2015 was a disaster for the 31-year old forward.

He routinely was a healthy scratch for the Hurricanes and at one point was actually sent to their AHL club — in a similar fashion to the Los Angeles Kings and Mike Richards.

Semin appeared in 57 games and produced just 19 points (6-13-19). However, some of this can be attributed to his career-low shooting percentage and a supporting cast that was lacking, to say the least.

NHL: OCT 28 Hurricanes at Canucks

The Hurricanes were a bad hockey team last season and not having Jordan Staal available for much of the season certainly did not help them at all. So would Semin be a fit with the Penguins? That depends.

What are the Pens willing to give up to acquire him and how much of his salary is Carolina willing to retain?

If they want center Brandon Sutter back, the Penguins should not make the trade. He’s entering the second year of a two-year, $6.6 million contract. The Penguins have very few trade assets and Sutter is one of their best options. They shouldn’t trade him unless it’s part of a deal to bring a quality top-six wing back.

At this point, Semin isn’t a very high quality top-six winger. He has an enormous amount of talent, but has been inconsistent and thought of as being temperamental. But would coming to the Penguins be a good move for Semin and Pittsburgh? If Carolina retains close to 50 percent of his salary and is not looking for a huge return, why not?

Star center Evgeni Malkin has never really played with another Russian forward and there are rumors that he would welcome the notion. Could Semin replicate the production he had with the Washington Capitals? It’s very likely he could.

Playing with Alexander Ovechkin and Nicklas Backstrom put him in a great position to be successful and Malkin is a much better center than Backstrom.

The bottom line is that Semin at $3.5 million (on the Penguins cap) is a great value. Playing with Malkin is an instant upgrade from anyone in Carolina and Semin bounce back to a point-per-game player.

Should the Penguins pursue Semin? It certainly looks to be a good idea, but like it was previously mentioned Rutherford knows him and signed him to that contract. Only time will tell if Rutherford would actually be willing to reacquire Semin, but at least on paper, it looks to be a pretty good move.

  • bobob

    Semin wasn’t sent to the AHL this past season…

  • Jim Estepp

    You lost me at “Malkin is a much better center than Backstrom.”

    I thought this would be a hockey site, but apparently commentary here is about as insightful as an ESPN highlight of a dunk. “Well, this guy is a better dunker, so he must be a much better player than that guy.”

    Malkin has more points than Backstrom, that much is true. Hopefully the position encompasses more than just how many points a player scores. Malkin has a lot more points than Toews as well.

    On everything else that embodies the position, Backstrom is vastly superior to Malkin. Unlike Malkin, Backstrom can actually win a faceoff. Unlike Malkin, Backstrom blocks shots from time to time. Of course, since Malkin can’t play defense, he isn’t trusted to play in shorthanded situations. I suppose two-way play isn’t a criteria for a center, either.

    Worry not, though, even on offense, Malkin isn’t much for defense, as he turns the puck over more than he takes it away, unlike, again, Backstrom. You can keep Malkin, and I’ll keep the complete NHL’er that is Backstrom.

    I wish Malkin luck covering for Semin’s mental midgetry and complete lack of effort on the defensive side of the puck. With both Semin and Malkin playing on the same line, the viewing public could be in for some plus/minus history.

    • Peblo Peet

      You think he’s better than Malkin? Backstrom would’t even agree with that.

      • Jim Estepp

        No. I said the statement the author made, calling Malkin “Much better than Backstrom” is patently false. Malkin is an elite offensive player, better than Backstrom on O, but, in every other aspect of the game, Backstrom is better than Malkin is.

        • Peblo Peet

          You can count the number of NHL teams that would take Backstrom over Malkin with zero hands.

Michael Pityk

Michael has served as a credentialed member of the media while covering the Philadelphia Phillies, Philadelphia Flyers, Pittsburgh Pirates and Pittsburgh Penguins and has seen his work regarding various sports teams featured on Sports Illustrated, The Sports Journal, MSN, PensLabyrinth, Montreal Hockey Talk, ESPN Pittsburgh, The Hockey Writers, Todays SlapShot and The Bleacher Report. He also serves as a Penguins and Flyers correspondent for The Hockey Writers and formerly was the Editor of Pens Labyrinth and Analyst for The Sports Journal. While he's with Today's Slapshot he will be talking everything and anything related to the Penguins.

More in Metropolitan

NHL: DEC 09 Islanders at Wild

Why a Kyle Okposo Trade Makes Sense for the Islanders

Franklin SteeleJune 23, 2015
NHL: MAR 09 Penguins at Maple Leafs

Penguins Can’t Afford a Phil Kessel Trade

Michael PitykJune 23, 2015
NHL: APR 07 Rangers at Devils

Rangers Need to Avoid Big Trade Temptation

Robert NassoJune 22, 2015
NHL: MAR 12 Flyers at Blues

Philadelphia Flyers Should Pursue T.J. Oshie

Zach HopkinsJune 22, 2015
NHL: OCT 25 Islanders at Penguins

4 Keys to a Pittsburgh Penguins Revival

Luke LapinskiJune 21, 2015
NHL: MAY 22 Eastern Conference Final - Game 4 Ð Rangers at Lightning

Henrik Lundqvist Not Leaving the Rangers for a Cup

Sebastian NorenJune 21, 2015